Formula 1 News

A case of what was, and what might have been

Fernando Alonso took a brilliant victory at the European Grand Prix, but there were several possible winners at various stages of the race. It could have turned very differently...
Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Rob Myers, Formula 1 fan since the era of Senna, Prost and Mansell tries to take an analytical approach and bring a fresh perspective through his Podium Finish blog.  He tweets at @RobLMyers.

June 26th, 2012 (F1plus / Rob Myers).- Who said that Valencia was a boring track? Another enthralling race in the topsy turvey 2012 Formula 1 season ended with three former world drivers’ champions on the podium, but perhaps not the three that might have been predicted before the race.

Fernando Alonso broke the run of different winners in each round of the championship so far with his second victory of the season at the European grand prix and was joined on the podium by Lotus’s Kimi Raikkonen and Mercedes AMG driver Michael Schumacher, who survived a post race stewards investigation for using his DRS under yellow flags and returned to the podium for the first time in his ‘second career’ in Formula 1.

It was undoubtedly a fantastic drive from Alonso, who started the race in 11th position, but with retirements for Red Bull’s Sebastian Vettel, Lotus’s Romain Grosjean and McLaren’s Lewis Hamilton – all of whom were in contention for victory – it was very much a case of what might have been for those drivers.

It wouldn’t be fair to Fernando Alonso not to start with him. As I’ve already mentioned, the Spaniard started the race in 11th place having failed to make it into the final part of qualifying. With the Ferrari having looked pretty uncompetitive in comparison to the other front running teams at this track, and with no-one having won at Valencia without qualifying in the top three, it looked highly unlike that Alonso would be able to challenge for victory, or even a podium.

Alonso though, as he has so often, particularly during the early part of the season, made light of these difficulties and drove a storming race to take his second victory of the season. His pass around the outside of Romain Grosjean at turn two, after the safety car had returned to the pits, was a particular high point of his race for me.

Alonso’s victory was all the more impressive when compared with the performance of his team-mate, Felipe Massa, who started the race just two places behind his team-mate, having set a time less than a tenth of a second slower than Alonso in qualifying.

While Alonso drove brilliantly from his midfield starting position, pushing at the right times, Massa finished in 16th place, a lap down after a collision with Sauber’s Kamui Kabayashi forced him to pit for a new nose.

Massa was perhaps a little unfortunate, but his performances throughout the season, when compared with those of his double world championship winning team-mate, are making it increasingly unlikely that he’ll retain his drive with Ferrari beyond this season. Alonso, though, with his ability to drag seemingly impossible results out of underperforming cars, now leads the championship. It would be hard to argue that Alonso has not been the outstanding driver of the season so far.

Moving on to the ‘what might have been’ drivers, Sebastian Vettel will regard himself extremely unlucky not to have won a race that he was completely dominating before the safety car was deployed on lap 30 following a collision between Toro Rosso’s Jean-Eric Vergne and Caterham’s Heikki Kovalainen.

The Red Bull driver had built up an impressive 20 second lead over Romain Grosjean, who had managed to overtake Lewis Hamilton, who had been running second since the start. Given Vettel’s dominant position at the half way point, few would have bet against the reigning world champion taking another victory at Valencia in a style reminiscent of some of his 2011 victories.

However, the intervention of the safety car proved crucial, eroding Vettel’s huge lead and, according to the German, possibly causing his eventual retirement with what turned out to be an alternator failure on lap 35. Vettel can certainly consider himself to have been hugely unfortunate at Valencia. We’ll never know whether he would have retired without the intervention of the safety car, but whether or not that would have been the case, he drove an outstanding first half of the race and would likely have won without the alternator issue.

Another driver that retired with an alternator failure was Romain Grosjean. The young Frenchman had driven another extremely impressive race brilliantly passing Lewis Hamilton for second place before the intervention of the safety car, and out racing his more experienced world championship winning team-mate, Kimi Raikkonen, before his unfortunate retirement, 16 laps from the end of the race.

Grosjean is another driver who can consider himself to have been unlucky at Valencia. The intervention of the safety car put the Lotus driver in contention to win the race, as he sat in second place to Vettel at the restart, but he was caught out by Alonso at the restart, dropping to third place after being overtaken by the Spaniard.

With Vettel’s retirement, though, Grosjean was once again running second and in with a real chance of challenging Alonso for victory. The Lotus driver said after the race “I think I was looking not too bad and we knew we were quicker than the Ferrari. We just had to wait a little bit to see if their tyres were going away then try to push”. As it turned out, Grosjean did not get the chance to prove that the Lotus was the faster car. But for his alternator failure – the second Renault engine car to suffer this fate – we might have had a great battle between Grosjean and Alonso.

Finally, Lewis Hamilton drove a strong race in a McLaren which was clearly not the fastest car on the track. Hamilton commented after the race that “We were a long, long way off today…we’ve got a lot of work to do to try and pick up the pace because we were really struggling today”, but despite the McLaren’s lack of pace – further demonstrated by another lacklustre result for Jenson Button, who finished in eight place – Hamilton might have won the race had it not been for another poor pit stop by the McLaren team.

The Woking based team have been working hard on their pit stops, having suffered a number of embarrassing delays in earlier races, and have introduced attached wheel nuts and a new, Ferrari style, pivoting front jack in order to cut down on the potential for problems and speed up their pit stops.

All their hard work seemed to be paying off with Hamilton’s first stop during which he was stationary for just 2.9 seconds. The second stop was another matter, however. A failure of one of McLaren’s new front jacks meant a second jack had to be used, but there were further problems even then.

In the end the delay was sufficient to drop Hamilton from third to sixth. BBC pundit Eddie Jordan commented after the race “I believe the poor pit stop cost Lewis the race because he would have been clear of Fernando Alonso, and Pastor Maldonado would have not got anywhere near him to knock him out of the race”.

It’s hard to disagree that another slow pit stop cost Hamilton dearly. The slow stop dropped Hamilton behind a number of cars that he would have been ahead of, cars that the Englishman then had to pass, wearing his tyres more than he otherwise would have done. As Eddie Jordan mentioned in his post race comments, Hamilton eventually crashed out of the race, having been rammed off by Williams driver Pastor Maldonado on the penultimate lap.

At that stage of the race, Hamilton was running in third position on tyres that had ‘dropped off the cliff’. The 2008 world champion had just been passed by 2007 champion Kimi Raikkonen and as Maldonado attempted to pass Hamilton defended his position, squeezing Maldonado off the track. The Venezuelan then rejoined and in doing so T-boned the McLaren pushing Hamilton into the wall and tearing off his own front wing.

This was another example of erratic and reckless driving from Maldonado who received a post race 20 second penalty from the stewards, dropping him front 10th to 12 place, costing him a world championship point. That would have been of little consolation to Hamilton, though, who failed to finish and failed to score points for the first time this season. As Eddie Jordan said, but for the poor second pit stop Hamilton would not have been in that position and, despite driving a car that was off the pace, he would have been in contention for victory.

It’s all ifs and buts for Hamilton, Grosjean and Vettel, though. In the end it was Alonso who took a deserved victory with another outstanding drive. Along with his win, the Ferrari driver also took the lead of the world drivers’ championship.

He has a 20 point lead over the second placed driver who, with retirements for Vettel and Hamilton, is now Mark Webber who drove a great race from 19th on the grid to finish fourth. For now it’s advantage Alonso, but with such an unpredictable season it’s a long way from game, set and match in the championship.

Your Comments


Formula 1 News

Monday, May 18, 2015

F1 changes yet to clear hurdles


F1 Standings

1 Lewis Hamilton 126
2 Nico Rosberg 116
3 Sebastian Vettel 98
4 Kimi Räikkönen 60
5 Valtteri Bottas 42
6 Felipe Massa 39
1 Mercedes 242
2 Ferrari 158
3 Williams F1 81
4 Red Bull Racing 52
5 Sauber 21
6 Sahara Force India 17

View complete standings table »


Last F1 Race

Monaco Grand Prix
Monte Carlo, Circuit of Monaco
Nico Rosberg
Sebastian Vettel
Lewis Hamilton
Fastest Lap


Pole Position

Lewis Hamilton

View all »


Follow Us