Formula 1 News

Pointing fingers the highlight of the "Testgate" hearing

Rivals watch on as arguments rage during today's session at the FIA International Tribunal.
Thursday, June 20, 2013

June 20th, 2013 (F1plus).- As expected, pointing fingers to each other was the norm today at the session. The main argument established by Mercedes is that the tyre manufacturer carried out the test, and therefore there should not be a case against the Brackley based outfit.

Mercedes is also trying to bring Ferrari back into the issue, as they believe the test carried by Pirelli with a Ferrari from 2011 was seen as legal.

It was also relevant to note Red Bull's Christian Horner surprise appearance in Paris for the hearings.
 

But also at the FIA's Place de la Concorde headquarters were representatives of McLaren and Williams, as the governing body's lawyer clearly accused Mercedes of breaking the rules with its highly controversial Barcelona test last month.

"Any running on the track is deemed to be testing," the FIA's lawyer said.

"It is difficult to say that Mercedes gained no benefit," he added.

The FIA also alleged that Mercedes and Pirelli were "very odd" in how they went about seeking permission to test, having made "informal" calls and emails to Charlie Whiting and the governing body's legal department, but then going ahead with the test without obtaining clear answers.

Mercedes' lawyer hit back by arguing the Brackley based team did not actually break the rules, because the sporting regulations say only that a team may not 'undertake' a test.

"It is irrefutable it was a test undertaken by Pirelli," he said.

The Mercedes lawyer also accused Ferrari of doing more than 1000 kilometres of testing in the weeks before the Barcelona session, while admitting that having Lewis Hamilton and Nico Rosberg wear all-black helmets was a "regrettable" decision.

"We acknowledge this aspect was bound to raise suspicion," he acknowledged.

A bullish Pirelli, meanwhile, argued that it fully complied with its contract with the FIA, and insisted it cannot be punished because it is not a team or driver.

(GMM)

FIA Headquarters, Paris, France.20th June 2013.The hearing over the Mercedes tyre test is underway. (DPPI/LAT Photographic)

Your Comments

 

Next F1 Race

United Kingdom
Jul 5
United Kingdom

Formula 1 News

Monday, May 18, 2015

F1 changes yet to clear hurdles

F1plusStore

F1 Standings

Drivers
Teams
1 Lewis Hamilton 126
2 Nico Rosberg 116
3 Sebastian Vettel 98
4 Kimi Räikkönen 60
5 Valtteri Bottas 42
6 Felipe Massa 39
1 Mercedes 242
2 Ferrari 158
3 Williams F1 81
4 Red Bull Racing 52
5 Sauber 21
6 Sahara Force India 17

View complete standings table »

F1plusStore

Last F1 Race

Monaco Grand Prix
Monte Carlo, Circuit of Monaco
1
Nico Rosberg
Mercedes
2
Sebastian Vettel
Ferrari
3
Lewis Hamilton
Mercedes
Fastest Lap


0s

Pole Position

Lewis Hamilton

View all »

 

Follow Us